Dual juries returned verdicts in a homicide case involving a 2-year-old victim.
Dual juries returned verdicts in a homicide case involving a 2-year-old victim.
Chandy McCarthy was found guilty by a jury of 2nd Degree Murder and Assault of a Child Under 8 Years Old Causing Death. A separate jury found Gregory Macdonald guilty of Involuntary Manslaughter and Child Abuse.
The case was prosecuted by Chief Deputy District Attorney Eric Smith.
On the evening of October 10, 2024, Bakersfield Police Department (BPD) Officers responded to a dispatch call in South Bakersfield for a report of a two-year-old barely breathing. Responding officers located the child, Shelly, who appeared to have been abused. Initial medical treatment was given to the victim, but she was later pronounced deceased at a local hospital. BPD Officers observed and photographed bruising throughout the victim’s body, including bruising on her back, buttocks, feet, knees, torso, face, lip, and below the ear.
Officers interviewed both the victim’s mother, Chandy McCarthy, and her boyfriend, Gregory Macdonald. Both defendants provided inconsistent statements that failed to justify the extensive evidence of abuse and trauma that the child suffered.
The victim’s cause of death was determined to be blunt force trauma and the manner of death was labeled a homicide.
DA Zimmer commented; “Homicide cases involving young children, particularly when committed by those who were entrusted with their care, are incredibly heartbreaking. This child deserved the opportunity to live a full life, and the individuals responsible for her death deserve to be held accountable for the unimaginable harm they have caused.”
McCarthy and Macdonald’s are expected to be sentenced on December 10, 2026.


